Custom Cakes

Order Now

Ready to elevate your next special event with a swoon-worthy custom cake? Sweet Tooth Bakes makes it easy to customize your dream cake. Simply select your decor package, size, and favorite flavor — and Janet takes care of the rest!

Standard

This package includes simple & tasteful decorative elements. These may include: name topper, stencil designs, gold accents, fault line, and minimal pearls.

Premium

In addition to the standard finishes, this package includes stunning finishes such as: chocolate covered styrofoam spheres, rice paper sail, simple fondant work, buttercream palette flowers, and butterflies.

Luxury

Choose this package for bespoke cakes that leave a lasting impression. This includes premium finishes as well as: chocolate sail, wafer paper sail, fondant figurine, plastic figurine, artificial flower, and buttercream piped flowers.

Decor Packages

Build Your Dream Cake

Check out the order form to see the sizing, flavors, and more. Our menu has clear transparent pricing to help you design the perfect cake for your big day!

Get Started

Exquisite Cakes for your Sweet Tooth

custom cakes made easy

Order

Submit an order inquiry to get the ball rolling. Share your vision as well as the size, flavor and date. This form is zero obligation.

Order Now

Confirm

Janet will review your order details, confirm availability and email you an invoice with a rough sketch within 2 business days. If there are any additional design questions she will clarify them at this stage.

Finalize

Simply submit your payment within 24 hours to finalize your order and reserve your date. Then sit back and relax — Janet will get busy baking your perfect treat! See you at your scheduled pickup or delivery.

Save your Date

Make your dream cake a reality. Place your inquiry today.

Order Now

It's love at first bite

Looking for Pure Vanilla? Try luscious vanilla-bean tender cake layers filled with silky smooth Italian meringue buttercream. Or perhaps your inner foodie is craving one of the many gourmet flavors like Janet's speciality — Mango Magic!

Explore the Menu

Do you offer cakes for dietary restrictions?

We do offer an egg-free option. We are unable to offer vegan, gluten free, nut free, or sugar free options at this time. While we take precautions to prevent cross-contamination, we cannot guarantee that our products are free from allergens.
Do you make fondant covered cakes?

Janet is known for her delicious Italian Buttercream cakes. While she does not offer fondant covered cakes, some decor packages do include the option for fondant accents.
Can you work from an inspiration photo?

Yes on the order form you will see an option to upload your inspiration photo(s). Please note that, these are only used for inspiration and are not intended for exact replication. Thank you for trusting us to design a unique, hand-crafted, work of art.
Do you take last minute orders?

When possible, to ensure availability, we recommend placing your order at least 2 weeks in advance. For inquiries needed within 1 week, we offer a Rush Service for an additional 10%. When schedules allow, we may be able to accommodate orders in as little as 48 hours.
Do you offer delivery?

We offer free pick ups or $50 delivery in Columbus, Indiana. Delivery is available elsewhere for an additional $1/mile.